With interest rates at all-time lows, some brokers are passing savings on to their retail investor base in the form of lower margin rates. This is great, allowing you to more cheaply leverage your portfolio. I won’t bore you with an unnecessary primer on what margin is; if you landed here, you likely already know. If you’re unfamiliar with what margin is, check out this post. For everyone else, let’s get right into a comparison of the investing brokers with the lowest margin rates for 2022.
Disclosure: Some of the links on this page are referral links. At no additional cost to you, if you choose to make a purchase or sign up for a service after clicking through those links, I may receive a small commission. This allows me to continue producing high-quality, ad-free content on this site and pays for the occasional cup of coffee. I have first-hand experience with every product or service I recommend, and I recommend them because I genuinely believe they are useful, not because of the commission I get if you decide to purchase through my links. Read more here.
Lowest Margin Rates Brokers Comparison Chart
Below is a chart comparing the margin rates of all the major brokers, assuming a margin loan of $100,000. Some brokers offer tiered rates that decrease slightly as your loan balance increases. I chose to compare $100,000 because that was the median tier in most of the rate tables of these brokers. Rates were taken directly from the broker’s website. Rates may vary.
So basically we’re down to M1 Finance, Interactive Brokers, and Robinhood for the lowest margin rates. All offer commission-free investing. Let’s compare some of the nuances.
First, let’s talk about Interactive Brokers. The minimum invested balance to access margin at Interactive Brokers is $100,000. The minimum for M1 Finance is only $2,000.
Unfortunately, the Interactive Brokers interface is very bad and downright unintuitive and confusing, especially for a beginner investor. Interactive Brokers is definitely only suitable for sophisticated, seasoned investors and traders. Here’s their interface:
The interface for M1 Finance, on the other hand, is extremely simple and intuitive:
IB’s customer service is also notoriously pretty awful. In fairness, if you’re an experienced trader, you may never actually need to contact Support.
Granted, if you’re an active day trader and want access to futures, options, and currencies, go with Interactive Brokers over M1.
Now let’s briefly address Robinhood. In short, I think the platform may not even have a future after recent events.
Robinhood experienced outages on 3 days during one week in March 2020, which they stated was caused by “stress on our infrastructure—which struggled with unprecedented load.” One of these outages lasted an entire trading day. This was obviously very frustrating and concerning for users, especially considering these were high-volume, high-volatility days in the stock market.
Robinhood users have since filed a class-action lawsuit against the platform, alleging that “Robinhood had a duty to provide a system and platform ‘robust enough’ to handle that trading volume and have a backup system to handle outages.”
In December 2020, the SEC fined Robinhood $65 million for misleading users about its selling of order flow between 2015 and 2018, meaning users got worse trade execution prices than the platform claimed. Robinhood maintains that these were “historical practices that do not reflect Robinhood today.”
In the same week, the Massachusetts Securities Division filed a lawsuit against Robinhood, alleging that the broker uses “gaming strategies to manipulate customers” to execute more trades in order to boost fees, thereby taking advantage of inexperienced investors.
There are also many user complaints such as these of the site being “frozen,” orders not going through, inability to login, etc.
One could argue that these events may cause Robinhood to improve their infrastructure going forward to make sure this doesn’t happen again in the future. On the other hand, it is concerning considering other brokers did not experience these outages and issues during that same time period. I’ve already seen many users running from Robinhood in droves and finding alternatives in platforms like Webull, M1 Finance, etc. It will be interesting to see how things go going forward for Robinhood.
Perhaps most importantly, Robinhood users have been fleeing en masse after the broker’s recent stance on temporarily blocking users from buying stocks like GameStop ($GME) and AMC Entertainment ($AMC) during the massive short squeeze event. As of February 1, 2021, over 33 federal lawsuits have been filed against the platform across the country, citing securities trading and consumer protection violations, which add insult to injury after Robinhood hid the fact that it sold order flow and gave users worse trade execution prices.
The name of the platform now seems ironic, considering Robinhood seems to be placating hedge funds and Wall Street hotshots – at the expense of retail investors – at every turn.
I think M1 is probably the best of these.
Customer service from M1 started off slow when the platform first launched but M1 has famously recently hired a team of new staff members to man the phone lines. Interactive Brokers also doesn’t provide access to an integrable checking account like you can with M1 Finance via M1 Spend.
Perhaps the most important difference though is the fact that margin from Interactive Brokers can only be used to leverage your portfolio with them (i.e. buy more securities), whereas a margin loan from M1 Finance can be used for whatever you want – refinancing higher-interest debt, major purchases, unexpected expenses, etc. – it’s essentially just a low-interest collateralized loan.
Remember that margin (in this case, via M1 Borrow) is an additional risk, including the risk of losing more than you invest. M1 Borrow is available for margin accounts with $2,000 or more in equity. M1 Borrow is not available for retirement or custodial accounts. Rates may vary.
M1 also offers fractional shares, zero transaction fees, zero account fees, and dynamic rebalancing. I wrote up a comprehensive review of it here. I also discussed M1’s margin loan product – called M1 Borrow – in a separate post here.
What Is Margin?
The term margin simply refers to money borrowed against your portfolio, where your investments are collateral for the loan, usually to enhance one’s exposure. “Buying on margin” means using that margin loan to buy more securities in your investment portfolio, thereby leveraging it.
Margin is similar to a HELOC. Just as a bank can lend you money if you have equity in your home, your brokerage firm can lend you money against the value of your investment portfolio.
Most require a minimum invested balance to be able to access margin. One must also pay periodic interest payments based on the margin rate, the interest rate of the margin loan.. Margin obviously becomes advantageous when your rate of return is higher than the interest on the margin loan.
If the value of your investments falls below a specified “maintenance requirement,” you’ll incur what’s called a margin call, where the broker demands funds to bring the account back to the maintenance level. This requires either depositing new cash or selling your investments. If you cannot meet the requirement, the broker will automatically close your positions to bring your account to the maintenance level.
Advantages of Margin
Margin allows you to enhance your investment exposure, increasing your position. This is great if the market is going up, but can be bad if the market tanks. If you have an account in which you deposit $10,000 and your broker allows you to borrow $10,000, you now have $20,000 in buying power and can therefore double your exposure to your investments.
Margin can also be a source of credit with no credit check and no repayment schedule. You can borrow against your portfolio and use the margin loan to cover emergency expenses. This allows you to avoid selling securities in your account and incurring capital gains taxes. Margin loans are generally cheaper than other forms of credit like a bank loan or credit card.
Let’s look at an example.
Suppose you invest $10,000 of your own money and your investment increases in value by 50% to $15,000, a gain of $5,000. Had you invested with margin, borrowing an additional $10,000 for a position of $20,000, your investment would be worth $30,000 after the 50% gain, doubling your return.
Now let’s make it a more complete example by including the margin interest at an 8% interest rate. With your $10,000 margin loan above, your interest on the loan is $800.
With an account with $10,000 and a margin loan of $10,000, your portfolio is said to be 2x leveraged – your buying power is 2x the amount of your initial capital. Unlike leveraged ETF products, with margin loans, your leverage ratio changes based on the performance of your investments. Because of this, the amount you can borrow changes daily. You can borrow more if your investments increase in value, and you can borrow less if your investments decrease in value.
Hopefully at this point you realize that if you borrow on margin, you can lose more than the amount deposited in your investment account. Suppose in the previous example the investment had instead dropped by 75%. Your $20,000 investment with margin would be worth $5,000, lower than your initial collateral. This is when a margin call occurs where you have to cover the deficiency. This simplistic example doesn’t even include the interest on the margin loan – $800 (8% of $10,000). In short, margin/leverage can magnify your gains but can also magnify your losses.
Most firms have a maintenance requirement around 30%, meaning you must have at least 30% in actual equity of the value of your account. Maintenance requirements from your broker may change without written notice. Furthermore, when you incur a margin call, brokers can sell your securities without notice if you are unable to replenish the discrepancy with newly deposited cash. The broker will likely notify you, but they are not required to. In such a case, you’re unable to choose which specific securities are liquidated. You are also not entitled to an extension of time on a margin call.
It’s important to diversify your investments when investing with margin, so that you’re not concentrating your risk and increasing your chances of incurring a margin call, also known as a maintenance call. That is, don’t use margin to buy a single stock. Furthermore, if margin investing doesn’t fit your particular risk tolerance, don’t entertain the idea to begin with.
You get to choose the amount you borrow. Buying 25% on margin (33% borrowed) is much more sensible, for example, than buying 50% on margin (100% borrowed). The more money you borrow, the more risk you take on. This is why diversification is increasingly important with margin loans as your amount borrowed increases. A higher amount borrowed also increases your chances of a margin call. You can be responsible with margin by only borrowing a small amount, paying margin interest regularly, and monitoring your investments.
Note that certain securities cannot be bought on margin, such as penny stocks. Brokers may also exclude certain high-risk securities at their discretion. Also note that margin loans cannot be used in retirement or custodial accounts.
Should You Use Margin?
Again, whether or not you employ margin/leverage comes down to your investing strategy and risk tolerance. You must use a sufficiently-diversified portfolio if you are going to use margin/leverage. Carefully weigh the pros and cons and understand how margin works before diving in.
Assess what leverage ratio will allow you to sleep easily at night. Consider starting low and slow and work your way up as your investments [hopefully] appreciate in value.
Alternatively, if you need access to short-term emergency credit for emergencies, margin is a perfectly suitable alternative to credit cards or bank loans and will likely have a lower interest rate. Check your broker’s margin rate for comparison.
Disclosure: Again, remember that margin is an additional risk, including the risk of losing more than you invest. Margin is not available for retirement or custodial accounts. Rates may vary.
Disclaimer: While I love diving into investing-related data and playing around with backtests, I am in no way a certified expert. I have no formal financial education. I am not a financial advisor, portfolio manager, or accountant. This is not financial advice, investing advice, or tax advice. The information on this website is for informational and recreational purposes only. Investment products discussed (ETFs, mutual funds, etc.) are for illustrative purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or otherwise transact in any of the products mentioned. Do your own due diligence. Past performance does not guarantee future returns. Read my lengthier disclaimer here.
Don't want to do all this investing stuff yourself or feel overwhelmed? Check out my flat-fee-only fiduciary friends over at Advisor.com.