• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Optimized Portfolio

Investing and Personal Finance

  • Start Here
  • Investing 101
    • Beginners Start Here – 10 Steps To Start Building Wealth
    • What Is the Stock Market? How It Works & How to Invest in It
    • How To Invest in an Index Fund – The Best Index Funds
    • Portfolio Asset Allocation by Age
    • How To Invest Your Emergency Fund
    • Portfolio Diversification – How To Diversify Your Portfolio
    • Dollar Cost Averaging vs. Lump Sum Investing (DCA vs. LSI)
    • How To Invest Your HSA (Health Savings Account)
    • Factor Investing and Factor ETFs – The Ultimate Guide
    • more…
  • Lazy Portfolios
    • All Weather Portfolio
    • Bogleheads 3 Fund Portfolio
    • HEDGEFUNDIE’s Excellent Adventure
    • Warren Buffett Portfolio
    • Golden Butterfly Portfolio
    • Paul Merriman Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio
    • Ben Felix Model Portfolio
    • Permanent Portfolio
    • David Swensen Portfolio
    • 60/40 Portfolio
    • more…
  • Funds
    • VOO vs. VTI – Vanguard S&P 500 or Total Stock Market ETF?
    • The 7 Best International ETFs
    • The 8 Best Small Cap ETFs (4 From Vanguard)
    • The 5 Best REIT ETFs
    • The 5 Best EV ETFs – Electric Vehicles ETFs
    • VIG vs. VYM – Comparing Vanguard’s 2 Popular Dividend ETF’s
    • The Best Vanguard Dividend Funds – 4 Popular ETFs
    • The 5 Best Tech ETFs
    • The 7 Best Small Cap Value ETFs
    • The 6 Best ETFs for Taxable Accounts
    • The 5 Best Emerging Markets ETFs (1 From Vanguard) for 2023
    • more…
  • Leverage
    • What Is a Leveraged ETF and How Do They Work?
    • How To Beat the Market Using Leverage and Index Investing
    • The 9 Best Leveraged ETFs
    • Hedgefundie’s Excellent Adventure
    • Leveraged All Weather Portfolio
    • Leveraged Permanent Portfolio
    • Leveraged Golden Butterfly Portfolio
    • NTSX – Review and Summary
    • TQQQ – Is It A Good Investment?
    • PSLDX – A Review
    • SWAN – A Review
    • RPAR Risk Parity ETF Review
    • more…
  • Dividends
    • The Best M1 Finance Dividend Pie
    • The 11 Best Dividend ETFs
    • The Best Vanguard Dividend Funds – 4 Popular ETFs
    • VIG vs. VYM – Comparing Vanguard’s 2 Popular Dividend ETF’s
    • 8 Reasons Why I’m Not a Dividend Income Investor
    • QYLD – A Harsh Review
    • more…
  • Brokers
    • The 5 Best Stock Brokers
    • The 4 Best Investing Apps
    • M1 Finance Review
    • Brokers with the Lowest Margin Rates
    • M1 Finance vs. Fidelity
    • M1 Finance vs. Vanguard
    • Webull vs. Robinhood
    • Stash vs. Robinhood
    • M1 Borrow Review (How M1’s Margin Loan Works)
    • more…
  • Retirement
    • The 10 Best ETFs for Retirement Portfolios in 2023
    • The 4% Rule for Retirement Withdrawal Rate – A Revisitation
    • Sequence of Return Risk in Retirement Explained
    • Traditional IRA Explained
    • Roth IRA Explained
    • 401k vs. Roth IRA
    • Roth IRA vs. Traditional IRA
    • Backdoor Roth IRA Explained
    • more…
  • My Toolbox

VYM vs. HDV – Vanguard Dividend ETF vs. iShares Dividend ETF

Last Updated: August 27, 2022 1 Comment – 3 min. read

Two popular dividend ETFs are VYM, the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF, and HDV, the iShares Core High Dividend ETF. They differ more than you may realize. Let’s compare them.

First, note that I don’t chase dividends. But I recognize that many investors use dividends to supplement their current income, particularly in retirement. Others just irrationally prefer dividend-paying stocks. I even designed a dividend-focused portfolio for income investors. In any case, these two funds are very popular and take a somewhat different approach. Here we’ll review these dividend ETFs and explore the differences between them.

Disclosure:  Some of the links on this page are referral links. At no additional cost to you, if you choose to make a purchase or sign up for a service after clicking through those links, I may receive a small commission. This allows me to continue producing high-quality, ad-free content on this site and pays for the occasional cup of coffee. I have first-hand experience with every product or service I recommend, and I recommend them because I genuinely believe they are useful, not because of the commission I get if you decide to purchase through my links. Read more here.

In a hurry? Here are the highlights:

  • VYM and HDV are two popular dividend ETFs from Vanguard and iShares, respectively.
  • VYM launched in 2006 and HDV launched in 2011.
  • Both funds capture high-dividend-yield stocks in the United States.
  • HDV costs a tiny bit more at 0.08%, while VYM costs 0.06%.
  • VYM is more diversified both in terms of number of holdings and sector exposure.
  • Specifically, HDV only holds 75 stocks while VYM has nearly 450.
  • Dividend yield is very similar between these two, with HDV’s being only slightly higher.
  • VYM has outperformed HDV historically on both a general and risk-adjusted basis.
  • VYM has slightly greater liquidity than HDV.
  • Sector composition differs pretty significantly between these two funds.

Contents

  • Video
  • VYM vs. HDV – Methodology, Factors, Fees, and Dividend Yield
  • VYM vs. HDV – Sector Composition
  • VYM vs. HDV – Performance Backtest
  • Conclusion

Video

Prefer video? Watch it here:

VYM vs. HDV – Methodology, Factors, Fees, and Dividend Yield

VYM is the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF. It launched in 2006. VYM seeks to track the FTSE® High Dividend Yield Index. Its selection methodology is not super simple but not complex. VYM looks for U.S. stocks that have paid a dividend for at least the last 12 months, ranks them by forecasted dividend yield for the next 12 months, excludes REITs, selects the top 50%, and then weights them by market cap. VYM is certainly focused on yield, but its market cap weighting scheme keeps its 450 or so holdings well diversified across sectors.

HDV launched in 2011. It is the iShares Core High Dividend ETF. Its index is the Morningstar Dividend Yield Focus Index. As the name suggests, HDV looks for high-yielding stocks, but it tries to make sure that yield is sustainable by employing some Morningstar earnings screens in its selection process. This process makes it a bit more complex than VYM.

First, firms must have a “moat” that gives them a competitive advantage. Then ratios like debt to equity are analyzed to try to identify firms with strong profitability and cash flow. REITs are excluded here too. What sets HDV apart arguably the most from VYM is the fact that it then takes the 75 highest-yield stocks and weights them from greatest to least by dividend dollar amount, not yield per se.

VYM and HDV have an overlap by weight of about 40%. This is illustrated more clearly in the very different sector compositions of these two funds below.

VYM could be considered more diversified than HDV, both in terms of number of holdings and sector exposure.

In terms of factors, both funds have positive loadings on Value, Profitability, and Investment, but HDV’s are considerably higher for those last two thanks to its profitability screens. Both funds also tilt large with negative loadings on Size, and HDV tilts slightly larger than VYM.

While VYM and HDV both have significant assets, VYM is much more popular than HDV by about $30 billion in assets. VYM is also slightly cheaper at 0.06% compared to 0.08% for HDV. Traders may also appreciate the smaller spread of VYM at 0.01%, compared to 0.02% for HDV.

At the time of writing, HDV has a slightly higher yield by about 1/10 of a percent at 3.15%.

VYM vs. HDV – Sector Composition

VYMHDV
Basic Materials4.9%0.2%
Consumer Staples13.7%16.8%
Consumer Discretionary8.7%1.8%
Financials23.0%6.6%
Healthcare12.6%23.1%
Industrials9.2%6.5%
Energy7.0%18.5%
Technology10.0%12.8%
Telecommmunications3.3%6.1%
Utilities7.3%7.5%
Real Estate0.0%0.0%

Notice how VYM massively overweights Financials, while HDV massively overweights Healthcare and Energy stocks and has negligible exposure to Materials and Consumer Discretionary stocks.

VYM vs. HDV – Performance Backtest

Here’s a performance backtest of VYM and HDV going back to HDV’s inception in 2011 and looking through 2021:

vym vs hdv performance
Source: PortfolioVisualizer.com

During that time, VYM has beaten HDV on both a general and risk-adjusted basis, with lower volatility and a smaller max drawdown.

Conclusion

In conclusion, HDV’s basket of only 75 stocks and negligible weightings to several sectors make it a bit too underdiversified for my tastes. It would certainly not be suitable as a core holding for a well-diversified portfolio, particularly if you want any exposure to REITs, small caps, mid caps, or international stocks.

Choosing between these two, going with VYM also gets you greater liquidity and saves you some on fees.

Conveniently, both VYM and HDV should be available at any major broker, including M1 Finance, which is the one I’m usually suggesting around here.

Do you own either of these dividend funds in your portfolio? Let me know in the comments.


Disclaimer:  While I love diving into investing-related data and playing around with backtests, I am in no way a certified expert. I have no formal financial education. I am not a financial advisor, portfolio manager, or accountant. This is not financial advice, investing advice, or tax advice. The information on this website is for informational and recreational purposes only. Investment products discussed (ETFs, mutual funds, etc.) are for illustrative purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell, or otherwise transact in any of the products mentioned. Do your own due diligence. Past performance does not guarantee future returns. Read my lengthier disclaimer here.

m1


Don't want to do all this investing stuff yourself or feel overwhelmed? Check out my flat-fee-only fiduciary friends over at Advisor.com.

77 percent of millenials report their finances are a source of anxiety

Related Posts

  • William Bernstein No Brainer Portfolio Review and ETFs To Use (2023)
  • VTI vs. VTSAX – Vanguard US Stock Market ETF or Mutual Fund?
  • SPHD ETF Review – Is SPHD a Good Investment? (Dividend Stocks)
  • Portfolio Rebalancing Explained – What, When, Why, and How
  • M1 Finance vs. TD Ameritrade Brokerage Comparison (2023)

About John Williamson

Analytical and entrepreneurial-minded data nerd, usability enthusiast, Boglehead, and Oxford comma advocate. I lead the Paid Search marketing efforts at Gild Group. I'm not a big fan of social media, but you can find me on LinkedIn and Reddit.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. James says

    January 26, 2023 at 2:01 am

    HDV is available in my 401K whereas VYM is not. I have been investing in the fund for several years now, and it does seem to have a really high yield. I read somehwhere that the yield is 3.57% whereas VYM is 3.00%.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Patreon

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates when a new post is published.

Don't worry, I hate spam too. No ads.

Most Popular

Ray Dalio All Weather Portfolio Review, ETFs, & Leverage (2023)

HEDGEFUNDIE’s Excellent Adventure (UPRO/TMF) – A Summary

Golden Butterfly Portfolio Review and M1 Finance ETF Pie

David Swensen Portfolio (Yale Model) Review and ETFs To Use

Harry Browne Permanent Portfolio Review, ETFs, & Leverage (2023)

Corporate Bonds vs. Government Bonds (Treasuries) – The Showdown

VIG vs. VYM – Vanguard’s 2 Popular Dividend ETFs (Review)

Warren Buffett ETF Portfolio (90/10) Review and ETFs (2023)

The 60/40 Portfolio Review and ETF Pie for M1 Finance

Bogleheads 3 Fund Portfolio Review and Vanguard ETFs (2023)

m1 sidebar

rocket money

m1 sidebar

visor sidebar

retirable

Paul Merriman Ultimate Buy and Hold Portfolio Review, M1 Pie (2023)

Lowest Margin Rates Brokers (2023 Comparison)

M1 Finance vs. Vanguard Brokerage Comparison [2023 Review]

M1 Finance vs. Fidelity Brokerage Comparison [2023 Review]

The Best M1 Finance Dividend Pie for FIRE & Income Investors

Portfolio Asset Allocation by Age – Beginners To Retirees

The 5 Best Stock Brokers Online for Investing (2023 Review)

The 4 Best Investing Apps for Beginners (2023 Review)

The 7 Best Small Cap ETFs (3 From Vanguard) for 2023

The 6 Best REIT ETFs To Invest in Real Estate for 2023

The 6 Best Tech ETFs To Buy Tech Stocks in 2023

9 Best Clean Energy ETFs To Go Green in Your Portfolio (2023)

The 13 Best Small Cap Value ETFs (3 From Vanguard) for 2023

Why, How, & Where To Invest Your Emergency Fund To Beat Inflation

VOO vs. VTI – Vanguard’s S&P 500 and Total Stock Market ETFs

9 Best International ETFs To Buy (6 From Vanguard) in 2023

Ben Felix Model Portfolio (Rational Reminder, PWL) ETFs & Review

Factor Investing and Factor ETFs – The Ultimate Guide

Gone Fishin’ Portfolio Review (Alexander Green) & ETFs (2023)

TQQQ – Is It A Good Investment for a Long Term Hold Strategy?

Recent Posts

Roth IRA vs. Traditional IRA – Which Is Better for You? (2023)

VXUS vs. IXUS – Vanguard or iShares International ETF?

Tail Risk – What It Is and How To Hedge Against It

I Bonds Explained (US Savings Bonds) – Ultimate Guide (2023)

JEPI ETF Review – JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF

Sharpe Ratio vs. Sortino vs. Calmar – Risk Adjusted Return

Portfolio Risk Explained – How To Think About Risk and Volatility

HNDL ETF Review – Is HNDL a Good Investment? (7HANDL™ ETF)

NUSI ETF Review – Is NUSI a Good Investment?

3 Best SPAC ETFs To Invest in SPACs in 2023 – But Should You?

VOO vs. VOOV vs. VOOG – Vanguard S&P 500, Value, or Growth?

VXUS vs. VEU – Which Vanguard Total International ETF?

VT vs. VTI – Global Stock Market vs. Total U.S. Stock Market

RPAR Risk Parity ETF Review – An All Weather Portfolio ETF?

PSLDX – A Review of the PIMCO StocksPLUS® Long Duration Fund

View All...

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Patreon

Amazon Affiliate Disclosure

OptimizedPortfolio.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates when a new post is published.

Don't worry, I hate spam too. No ads.

About - My Toolbox - Privacy - Terms - Contact


Copyright © 2023 OptimizedPortfolio.com

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Ok, Got ItReject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT